¶ Wilburn v. Guthrie anti-SLAPP appeal and cert petition
This source cluster summarizes the Wilburn v. Guthrie litigation materials now in the repository, which show how a D20 campaign-forum controversy turned into a defamation and anti-SLAPP dispute over whether Guthrie's accusations were protected opinion or actionable factual assertions.
The cluster consists of Guthrie's Colorado Court of Appeals opening brief, Wilburn's answer brief, the published Colorado Court of Appeals opinion, and Guthrie's Colorado Supreme Court cert petition and appendix. The existing D20 summary provides the surrounding school-governance context for why the dispute matters inside the repository.
- The litigation grows out of an October 4, 2023 Academy District 20 candidate forum where Derrick Wilburn read explicit passages from books while arguing against their availability in school libraries.
- The appellate materials agree on the broad procedural frame: Wilburn later sued Guthrie for defamation and outrageous conduct, Guthrie filed a special motion to dismiss under Colorado's anti-SLAPP statute, the district court denied that motion, and Guthrie pursued an interlocutory appeal.
- The Court of Appeals opinion holds that some of Guthrie's statements were protected opinion when they fully and accurately disclosed the conduct on which her accusations were based, but that other statements could still be actionable because they lacked that context or implied facts not established by the disclosed conduct.
- The opinion therefore affirms denial of the anti-SLAPP motion while directing that the case be narrowed on remand rather than allowing every challenged statement to proceed unchanged.
- The cert petition shows Guthrie seeking Colorado Supreme Court review on three issues: the disclosed-facts opinion rule, the proper second-step anti-SLAPP standard, and whether serial statements should be evaluated as a whole rather than in isolation.
- Inside the Colorado education-governance corpus, the dispute matters because it converts a school-board moral-panic conflict into an appellate record about intimidation, defamatory accusation, and the legal limits of political speech in a public-school controversy.
¶ Parties and procedural posture
- Bernadette Guthrie is the defendant-appellant in the court of appeals and the petitioner in the cert petition.
- Derrick Wilburn is the plaintiff-appellee in the court of appeals and the respondent in the cert petition.
- The district-court case is identified in the appellate materials as El Paso County District Court
24CV32374.
- The court-of-appeals case is identified as
2025CA776 or 25CA0776.
- The published opinion is
2026COA13, announced March 12, 2026.
- The existing D20 summary already framed Wilburn as a recurring actor in candidate-network and intimidation disputes. The legal documents strengthen that cluster by showing that the rhetoric around the candidate-forum controversy produced a sustained anti-SLAPP and defamation fight rather than only commentary-site accusations.
- The opinion supplies a narrower and more reliable description of the dispute than the advocacy material alone, especially on the difference between disclosed-opinion statements and accusations that may imply undisclosed defamatory facts.
- The cert petition also shows that the dispute is being framed as a potentially broader Colorado anti-SLAPP and free-speech case, not only as a local school-board quarrel.
¶ Evidence limits and open questions
- The repository currently has appellate briefs, the court-of-appeals opinion, and the cert petition materials, but not the full district-court complaint, motion record, or any final Colorado Supreme Court disposition.
- The opinion clearly narrows which statements can support Wilburn's claims, but the current corpus does not show what ultimately happens to the narrowed case after remand.
- The exact dates of some underlying 2023-2024 background events, especially the parent petition and some public-comment sequence, are described in relative rather than fully docketed terms in the opinion.
- Board of Education Special Meeting - Jan 08 2026 Minutes
- Board of Education Regular Meeting - Jan 08 2026 Minutes
- Board of Education Study Session - Jan 08 2026 Minutes
- Board of Education Spring Retreat - Mar 12 2026
- Board of Education Study Sessions - Mar 12 2026
- Board of Education Regular Meeting - Mar 12 2026
- 49170.pdf
- Special Board Meeting - January 28, 2026 Minutes
- Regular Board Meeting - March 4, 2026
- 68856.pdf
- 70872.html
- 70013.html
- 71962.html
- 71963.pdf
- Regular Board of Education Meeting - Oct 09 2025 Minutes
- Minutes October 22, 2025
- Regular Board of Education Meeting - Jan 16 2026 Minutes
- Regular Board of Education Meeting - Mar 12 2026
- Regular Board of Education Meeting - Apr 09 2026
- 24018.pdf
- 24919.html
- 24920.pdf
- 14596.html
- 14597.pdf
- 32620.html
- 32810.pdf
- Weld RE-4 Google Docs board-material recapture batch
- 2026-01-08-special-meeting-agenda-1n9ka4ua.txt
- 2026-01-08-special-meeting-minutes-1jjm1h0u.txt
- 2026-01-09-retreat-agenda-15dh06qv.txt
- 2026-01-09-retreat-minutes-1xr6mk93.txt
- 2026-01-12-regular-meeting-agenda-1hlr2w97.txt
- 2026-01-12-regular-meeting-minutes-1tu9wwge.txt
- 2026-02-02-work-session-agenda-1ucp1yli.txt
- 2026-02-02-special-meeting-minutes-1tom0qge.txt
- 2026-02-09-regular-meeting-agenda-1osjvk0y.txt
- 2026-02-09-regular-meeting-minutes-12wljf9h.txt
- 2026-03-02-special-meeting-agenda-1bzykuk.txt
- 2026-03-02-special-meeting-minutes-12f-84es.txt
- 2026-03-09-regular-meeting-agenda-1b5zdhje.txt
- 2026-04-06-special-meeting-agenda-16temi3b.txt
- Special Board of Education Meeting - Jan 06 2026 Minutes
- Special Board of Education Meeting - Jan 26 2026 Minutes
- Special Board of Education Meeting - Jan 30 2026 Minutes
- Regular Board of Education Meeting - Feb 19 2026 Minutes
- 17902.pdf
- Board of Education Work Session - Apr 09 2026
- 18323.html
- 18324.pdf
- Special Board Meeting 02-18-26 Minutes
- Special Board Meeting 02-23-26
- Regular Board Meeting 03-11-26 Minutes
- Special Board Meeting 03-12-26 Minutes
- Special Board Meeting 03-16-26 Minutes
- Regular Board Meeting 04-08-26
- Rocky Mountain Black Conservatives home
- Rocky Mountain Black Conservatives about us
- Rocky Mountain Black Conservatives nonprofit explorer profile
- Rocky Mountain Black Conservatives full filing 2022
- POCC Internship home
- POCC Internship about us
- Charis Bible College home
- Charis Bible College Practical Government School
- Charis Bible College catalog 2023-2024
- Church Voter Guides D20 2023 school board voter guide
- Elect Derrick Wilburn TRACER candidate detail
- Truth and Liberty Derrick Wilburn Are Black Voters Shifting Conservative
- Spreaker Derrick Wilburn Changing Perspectives with Truth
- Spreaker Derrick Wilburn on Black Conservatives and More
- Spreaker The Truth and Liberty Show with Richard Harris Bishop E W Jackson and Derrick Wilburn
- State GOP vice chair Derrick Wilburn says he won't be seeking top party post
- What does it mean to be a Black conservative in Colorado?
- Ep. 4 - Back to Our FAITH, Back to Winning (Derrick Wilburn)
- Student Led Academy District 20 - Board of Education Candidate Forum
- Lawlessness Exposed with Dave Illingworth and Derrick Wilburn
- Franchised Outrage: Porn Panic, the Trans Athlete Pivot, and the Machinery of Manufactured Fear
- Dr. Bill Sawvel’s Dissertation Reveals the Playbook Behind His Book Bans
- Eddie Waldrep's Interview Raises Alarms About His Understanding of Public Education
- D20 Board Member Derrick Wilburn Tells Parent of Disabled Student to Leave the District - Fits Longstanding Pattern of Intimidation
- D20 Candidate Cynthia Halverson’s Patriot Academy Training: A Closer Look at the Network Behind Her Campaign
- Lawsuit Alleges D20 Board Candidate Defrauded Military Health Insurance
- ‘It’s Make-Believe,’ Colorado GOP Hears from Authors of Monument Academy’s Transgender Policy
- 2023 Review: the Colorado Times Recorder’s School Board Coverage
- CO Springs Board of Education Candidates Running on Trans Sports Bans
- School Board Candidates Field Culture War Questions at CO Springs Forum
- School Board Roundup: Who Won, Who Lost, and Where it’s Too Close to Call
- Say No to Colorado Leaders for Academic Success & School Boards For Academic Excellence
- D20 board director describes tenure on school board as a 'spiritual battle' at Christian event
- D20 school board quote triggers separation of church and state controversy
- Academy School District 20 Board President stepping down effective June 1
- Why you're getting so many political texts, and how they're giving candidates an advantage
- Daniel Fenlason
- D11 Momentum
- Superintendent is retiring after Colorado school board president urged parents to search schools for objectionable material
- Fire-Breathing Lesbians & Satan-Worshipping S.O.Bs: The Private Chat Logs of a Christian Conservative School District Group
- Leadership Institute Training: Action Items for Newly Conservative School Boards
- Seducing the Bride of Christ
- Dark Money and the School Board Industrial Complex
- Truth & Liberty | Promoting True Reformation Of Nations
- Our Team
- How the left treats our poor, sitting duck school board members.
- The school board saga continues
- Local school board nastiness - Installment #3
- School board saga takes a BIZARRE turn
- Engaged: Bringing Answers to the Darkness